Cultural perceptions of disabilities significantly influence how societies identify, support, and integrate individuals with special educational needs and disabilities (SEND). These perceptions shape educational policies, family decisions, and the lived experiences of those with disabilities. Understanding and challenging these cultural assumptions is crucial for fostering inclusive and supportive environments worldwide. Without knowledge and education, families of children with SEND risk becoming more isolated and as a result, children might not have access to the education they not only deserve but have to right to.
Stigma and Family Dynamics
In many cultures, disabilities are often stigmatized, leading to feelings of shame and isolation for both individuals with SEND and their families. For instance, in certain South Asian communities, disabilities may be associated with embarrassment, influencing families' decisions regarding educational placements and social interactions. This stigma can result in families opting to keep their children's disabilities hidden, thereby limiting their access to necessary resources and support. (Visible Magazine)
Similarly, in Nigeria, societal pressures and insufficient support systems exacerbate the challenges faced by families of children with disabilities. Nigerian singer Joy Eseoghene Odiete, known as Jodie, shared her personal experience of facing abandonment and societal abuse after her son was born with lissencephaly and cerebral palsy. Despite these challenges, she founded the Chinua Children Care Foundation to support other families in similar situations, advocating for better education and welfare systems. These are just a few examples taken from a very complex and articulated global picture.
SEND Assumptions in the West
In Western countries, there is a growing awareness of SEND, but cultural assumptions still impact how disabilities are perceived and addressed. While inclusion is often emphasized in policies, actual implementation can be inconsistent.
One major issue is the medicalized approach to SEND, where disabilities are often seen as individual deficits rather than as social constructs. This can lead to an overemphasis on diagnosis and treatment rather than systemic changes that could make education more accessible. In France, for example, despite policies promoting inclusion, progress has been slow, with many children with disabilities still being placed in specialized institutions rather than mainstream schools. (Le Monde)
In the United States and the UK, another assumption is that inclusive education alone is enough to support SEND students. While inclusion is important, many schools lack the resources, training, and staff needed to implement it effectively. As a result, students may be placed in mainstream classrooms without adequate support, leading to struggles with learning and social integration. In Italy, the tendency is for SEND children to be working in isolation with their keyworker rather than being included in whole-class activities. Additionally, in some Western media representations, such as the TV series The Good Doctor, autism and other disabilities are often portrayed in a way that does not reflect the diverse experiences of individuals with SEND. This can create unrealistic expectations and further misunderstandings.
Educational Implications and Cultural Competency
Cultural assumptions about disabilities directly impact educational practices and policies. In some cultures, disabilities are viewed through a medical lens, focusing on deficits and limitations. This perspective can lead to segregated educational settings and lower expectations for students with SEND. Conversely, adopting a social model of disability, which views disabilities as a result of societal barriers rather than individual deficits, can promote more inclusive educational practices. (American Speech-Language-Hearing Association).
These are just some of the reasons why cultural competency among educators and professionals is essential for addressing these biases and fostering inclusive environments. Understanding students' cultural backgrounds and the associated perceptions of disabilities can help educators develop more effective and respectful teaching strategies.
For example, recognizing that certain behaviors may be culturally influenced rather than indicative of a disability can prevent misdiagnosis and inappropriate educational placements. (MedBridge)
Global Perspectives and Inclusive Practices
The movement towards inclusive education has gained international momentum, with various multinational agreements and policies advocating for the rights of individuals with disabilities. However, the implementation of inclusive practices varies across cultures, influenced by local beliefs, resources, and societal attitudes. In some non-Western contexts, traditional approaches to special education may offer valuable insights. For instance, community-based rehabilitation and inclusive community practices have been effective in certain cultures, emphasizing the role of the community in supporting individuals with disabilities. (De Gruyter).
An example of a community-based intervention is the work of the Indian National Portage Association (INPA). During my time working with INPA in 2005, prioritizing community and family education on learning difficulties proved to be a crucial foundation for the child's successful rehabilitation process. As we shift our focus beyond Western countries, where individualism is often emphasized over communal support, it is essential to recognize that many cultures around the world view community life and collective care as integral to a child's well-being.
Challenging and Transforming Assumptions
So, what can we do?
To create more inclusive societies, it is imperative to challenge and transform existing cultural assumptions about disabilities. This transformation requires:
- Awareness and Education: Raising awareness about the diverse experiences of individuals with SEND and educating communities about the social model of disability can help shift perceptions.
- Policy and Advocacy: Advocating for policies that promote inclusion, accessibility, and equal opportunities is crucial. This includes ensuring that educational systems are equipped to support diverse learners.
- Community Engagement: Engaging with families, community leaders, and individuals with disabilities to understand their perspectives and co-develop solutions fosters a more inclusive environment.
By addressing and reshaping cultural assumptions, societies can move towards more equitable and supportive systems for individuals with special educational needs and disabilities.
Add comment
Comments